Monday, September 22, 2014

Who's Your Source?

Unless you live under a rock, you’ve probably heard that the Apple’s new iPhones were released this past weekend. Millions of people stood in line across the country to get in on the iPhone 6 and 6 Plus action. Some tech analysts are getting in on the action by commenting on why sales of the new phones have reached 10 Million dollars in the first weekend of sales. After reading “New iPhone Sales Top 10 Million in the First Weekend” (Chen & Isaac, 2014) in the New York Times online edition, I started to wonder who the analysts are that have given the new iPhones such praise.  Was this article written to generate buzz about the new product?  Or is this article truthful and forthcoming will all sides of the story? I decided backtrack the sources to prove that what I’ve read online in this article is factual.

I started with the authors of the article, Brian X. Chen and Mike Isaac.  My main goal with the authors was to find out what they’re credentials and connection to the subject are. What makes them qualified to discuss the impact of the new iPhones?  After a little research, I found that Brian X. Chen is a leader in the tech field.  Not only is he the technology reporter for the New York Times, he previously wrote about mobile phones at Wired.com.  He’s also written a book “Always On”, which discusses how the smartphone revolution has transformed our culture. The second author of the article is Mike Isaac. Isaac recently joined the New York Times as a tech reporter after a career as a senior editor at re/code and its predecessor, “AllThingsD” at the Wall Street Journal. Isaac is know for his tech savvy knowledge on everything from Facebook to Twitter to smartphones.  I can safely conclude that the authors have the qualifications for me to trust the article. In addition, knowing that the New York Times is a credible source for news, I am confident that Chen and Isaac have done the research needed to write the article.

In investigating the sources within the article, I found that each source is also credible.  In the article, Maynard Um, senior research analyst for Wells Fargo, confirmed the authors theory of the iPhones making tremendous sales by discussing the demand for the iPhone 6 Plus and the iPhone 6. Um covers the IT Hardware sector for Wells Fargo. In addition to IT hardware, Um followed a number of technology sectors, including Internet, PC Software and Wireless Equipment. The next source, Gene Munster of Piper Jaffray, is a managing director and senior research analyst. Munster has been covering digital media since 1995. Munster offered another view on the story by wondering if the iPhone sales are a reliable measure of consumer demand.  The article’s authors have now shown both sides of the stories. The final source in the article is Walter Piecyk, managing director at BTIG Research. Piecyks lengthy background in telecom service provider and communication equipment equities gives him the authority to confirm the theory of Apple’s chief executive, Timothy D. Cook, the iPhone sales are really dependent on how much Apple can supply.


While I can confirm that the information in this article is true, it’s imperative to know not all articles online are truthful. This article was found in the New York Times online edition. Because this news source is reputable, there was very little doubt in my mind that this story was less than truthful. However, I was able to backtrack the sources to confirm my initial thoughts. It’s up to the reader to have the knowledge and skills to decipher fact from fiction when reading online information.  Always check the author(s), date, type of website and whether the article is fair and balanced when considering the validity of the article.  Just remember, not everything you read online is true.


Chen, B & Issac, M. (September 22, 2014). New iPhone Sales Top 10 Million in First




No comments:

Post a Comment